Difference between revisions of "Operation and maintenance (O&M) of green roofs"
Operation and maintenance (O&M) of green roofs

Latest revision as of 13:45, 30 December 2022

Schematic showing the different components of a green roof. Thicknesses of some layers vary with the design (e.g. extensive vs. intensive roofs).

View of the Target Center Arena green roof, located in downtown Minneapolis, Minnesota. Image by Bergerson Photography, Courtesy of The Kestrel Design Group, Inc., INSPEC, and Leo A Daly.

Green Infrastructure: Green roofs consist of a series of layers that create an environment suitable for plant growth without damaging the underlying roof system. Green roofs create green space for public benefit, energy efficiency, and stormwater retention/ detention.

This page provides guidance for operation and maintenance (O&M) of green roofs. Green roofs consist of a series of layers that create an environment suitable for plant growth without damaging the underlying roof system. Green roofs create green space for public benefit, energy efficiency, and stormwater retention/detention.

Supplemental information can be found on the page called Operation and maintenance of green roofs - supplemental information. Supplemental information includes the following.

Weeding
Plant replacement
Irrigation
Fertilization
Soil tests
Photographical record

Overview of Typical O&M Issues

Green roofs are roofs that are partially or completely covered with vegetation planted in a growing medium that is underlain by an impermeable barrier. This does not include roofs with vegetation that can readily be moved, such as potted vegetation. Green roofs typically consist of a series of layers (waterproof membrane, growing medium, vegetation, etc) that create an environment suitable for plant growth without damaging the underlying roof system. Green roofs create green space for public benefit, provide energy efficiency for the building, and provide stormwater retention and detention. In addition, these practices can provide ecosystem services such as nutrient cycling and storage, carbon sequestration, reduction in heat island effect, climate adaptation, and habitat for bees, butterflies, and other insects and small animals that pollinate.

Green roofs require dedicated and regular maintenance to ensure proper and long-lasting operation and ecosystem services. Estimated green roof lifespans range from 40 to 50 years, or twice as long as traditional roofs (Porsche and Kohler, 2003; Arup, 2011). The most frequently cited O&M concerns for green roofs include

poorly drained green roofs and standing water due to poor design or drain blockage,
roof leaks from perforated membranes,
accumulation of trash and debris, and
growth and proliferation of weeds or other non- native species that threaten the function and/or the structural integrity of underlying green roof layers.

The sections below describe best practices to prevent or minimize these common problems.

Design Phase O&M Considerations

Vegetation free zones at Target Center Green Roof, Minneapolis, MN. Image courtesy of The Kestrel Design Group, Inc.

Green roofs can be designed and installed on existing structures, however, it is often easier to maintain green roofs that are designed as part of a new structure. This is because certain features of the green roof will be inside a building, and accounting for the layout of drain pipes and irrigation lines beforehand can make O&M access and tasks simpler than in a retrofit installation. O&M activities and access points, along with the structural support and drainage plans, should be carefully considered when planning a green roof addition. A successful green roof relies on a growing medium, access to a water source, and a plant species list that requires as little maintenance as possible. Access to the green roof should be limited to maintenance personnel only, because soil compaction from foot traffic will reduce the infiltration capacity of the growing medium, leading to flooding risks. Designers should design these practices in ways that prevent or minimize O&M issues. Examples include the following.

Designing the green roof with enough slope to prevent drainage issues while also optimizing for maximum stormwater retention and detention. However, to avoid media from being displaced (sliding), slopes should not exceed 2:12 unless reinforced. For more information on slope, link here.
Providing detailed specifications for the roof water-proofing membrane to prevent roof leaks.
If a larger green roof is intended to allow pedestrian foot traffic, designing a trail system that minimizes impact to vegetation and growing medium in order to prevent plant damage that requires maintenance/replacing, or soil compaction that could lead to flooding.
Providing a vegetation design plan, emphasizing native species plantings (see Plants for Stormwater Design and this link to green roof plants) to enhance pollinator and wildlife habitat, improve infiltration and evapotranspiration, reduce urban heat island effect, provide optimized carbon sequestration, and provide climate adaptation. Native plantings typically require less maintenance and replacement than non-native plantings because they are adapted to the local climate.
Include site-specific plantings that take into account sun exposure, shade, interior vs exterior plantings, etc. The selection of plantings suitable to their immediate surroundings will minimize long-term care and replacement frequency.
Specifying the optimized soil media composition and depth to effectively trap or sequester nutrients (phosphorus in particular), and that can also support the desired vegetation. This will also reduce maintenance in the long term.
Providing educational signage in appropriate locations to increase public awareness
Installing measures like low fencing to prevent damage from pedestrian foot traffic.

Designers should also recognize the need to perform frequent landscaping maintenance to remove trash, check for clogging, and maintain vigorous and healthy vegetation. Designers can incorporate design solutions to facilitate maintenance activities. Examples include

incorporating multiple and easy site access points for maintenance personnel that limit soil compaction when tending to vegetation,
creating easy site access to drain pipe clean out traps, and
providing recommendations of vegetation appropriate to the location.

The designer should also provide a site-specific O&M plan that includes the following.

Construction inspection schedule and checklists
Post-construction routine maintenance schedule and checklists
Operating instructions for the practice (if applicable)

Additional information that should be included in O&M plans is described in the Post-construction phase O&M considerations section. Example O&M plans are provided below.

For more detailed design information and criteria for green roofs, see the Design criteria for green roofs page.

Construction Phase O&M Considerations

Erosion control blanket and native plant plugs at Minneapolis City Hall Green Roof, Minneapolis, MN. Image courtesy of The Kestrel Design Group, Inc.

Proper construction methods and sequencing play a significant role in reducing O&M problems. Some key items during the construction phase include:

Before construction begins
1. Hold a pre-construction meeting with the designer and the installer to review the construction plans and the sequencing of construction. Other agenda items could include reviewing or assigning points of contacts for the stormwater and/or green infrastructure key personnel.
2. Review construction plans to ensure roof orientation and slope are appropriate.
3. Coordinate with licensed plumbers who are plumbing the building to discuss irrigation and drainage lines.
During construction
1. Conduct a roof leak test once the membrane layer is installed before adding the soil and plants, to ensure integrity of waterproof membranes
2. Install temporary and long-term erosion protection practices for when the vegetation is taking root and growing (to prevent clogging of the drainage system).
3. Ensure heavy equipment does not enter the footprint of the practice to avoid compaction of the growth medium.
4. Ensure the correct plant species are being installed by having a detailed list of species and quantities. These should be spelled out in the plan set both in the Details & Specifications and on actual drawings. A copy should be kept on one’s person at all times during construction.
5. Inspect the practice during construction to ensure that the green roof is built in accordance with the approved design and standards and specifications. Use a detailed inspection checklist that includes sign-offs by qualified individuals at critical stages of construction, to ensure that the contractor’s interpretation of the plan is acceptable to the professional designer. Example construction phase inspection checklists are provided below.
After construction
1. Verify that the green roof was built in accordance with the approved design and standards and specifications.
2. Verify that the practice properly captures and infiltrates precipitation. Conduct a full inundation test to inspect the underdrain and outflow function.
3. Verify that the practice reduces nutrient loads. Collect inflow and outflow storm water samples and have them analyzed for nutrient concentrations.
4. Use a detailed inspection checklists that include sign-offs by qualified individuals at the completion of construction, to ensure that the contractor’s interpretation of the plan is acceptable to the professional designer. Example construction phase inspection checklists are provided below.
5. Review and discuss the plant warranty/establishment period with the plant provider to understand the conditions under which failing plants will be replaced.
6. The design/construction team should provide the O&M team with the following information to be included in the O&M plan
  1. The plant warranty.
  2. The “ as-built” plans of the practice
  3. A list of conditions that might cause failure of the practice if not properly maintained.

Post-Construction Phase O&M

Effective short and long-term operation of green roofs require a dedicated and routine maintenance plan with clear guidelines, expectations, and schedules. Proper maintenance will not only increase the expected lifespan of the green roof but will improve aesthetics and property value. A maintenance plan clarifying maintenance responsibilities should be required for all practices. Important post-construction considerations are provided below along with recommended maintenance standards.

A site-specific Operations and Maintenance Plan should be prepared by the designer prior to putting the stormwater practice into operation. This plan should provide any operating procedures related to the practices. The plan should also provide clear maintenance expectations, activities, and schedules. Include photos if possible. Be clear about who is responsible for the maintenance and the type of expertise that will be needed for distinct O&M activities. The O&M plan should include an anticipated budget for O&M activities. The O&M plan should also include an example O&M inspection checklist and an example maintenance report. Example O&M plans and inspection checklists are provided further down below.
A legally binding and enforceable maintenance agreement should be executed between the practice owner and the local review authority. Example maintenance agreements are provided further down below.
Inspection and maintenance activities are distinct and can be done as separate activities or together. Inspection will typically assess the practice for any O&M issues, whereas maintenance will address the O&M issues identified by the inspection. A dedicated inspection effort on a large number of BMPs can help prioritize maintenance activities.
Maintenance activities should be careful not to cause compaction. No unauthorized foot traffic should be allowed within the footprint of the practice, unless otherwise accounted for during the design stage. A green roof will not typically see much foot traffic except by maintenance personnel. However, a larger roof may allow pedestrian foot traffic, in which case a trail system should be considered to minimize impact to vegetation and soils.
Ponding water is an indicator the green roof is not properly draining. If ponded water is observed outside of a routine O&M schedule it should be addressed immediately.
Monitor non-vegetated areas that function as long-term erosion control and repair as needed.

The table below provides an overview and schedule of general maintenance activities.Additional vegetation information can also be found in the vegetation pages.

Overview and schedule of general maintenance activities for green roofs
Link to this table

First Year of Operation
Activity	Frequency	Time period	Level of effort	O&M benefit^a
Check that there is no ponding	Bi-weekly	All year long	1-2 hours	1
Inspect roof drain for sediment, vegetation, or debris	Triannually or after 24hr-10yr event	All year long	1-2 hours	1
Inspect membrane and vegetation free zones	Bi-weekly	All year long	2-4 hours	1
Check erosion control measures	Bi-annually	All year long	1-2 hours	1
Weeding and invasives control	2-4 weeks during the growing season	Growing season	2-4 hours	2,4,5,6
Supplemental watering	When rainfall is <0.5 inches over 10-15 days	First growing season	2-4 hours	2,4,5,6
Inspect plant growth and growth medium	Biweekly	First growing season	2-4 hours	2,3,4,5,6
Remove and replace dead plants	As needed	First growing season	2-4 hours	2,3,4,5,6
Spot reseeding of bare patches and eroding areas	As needed	First growing season	2-4 hours	2,3,4,5,6
After First Year of Operation
Activity	Frequency	Time period	Level of effort	O&M benefit^a
Check that there is no ponding	Biannually	Any time when ground is not frozen	1-2 hours	1
Inspect membrane and vegetation free zones	Annually	All year long	2-4 hours	1
Inspect roof drain for sediment, vegetation, or debris	Triannually or after 24hr-10yr event	All year long	1-2 hours	1
Remove and replace dead plants	Biannually	Fall and Spring	2-4 hours	2,3,4,5,6
Weed and remove invasive plants	Twice during growing season	Growing season	2-4 hours	2,3,4,5,6
Supplemental watering	As needed during extended dry periods	Dry periods	1-2 hours	2,3,4,5,6
Inspect for and repair broken inlets or pipes	As needed	All year long	2-4 hours	1
Prune trees and shrubs, and cut back dead or excessive vegetation	Annually	In fall or spring	2-4 hours	2,3,4,5,6
Inspect growth medium for continued viability	Quarterly	All year long	2-4 hours	2,3,4,5,6
Fertilizing	Twice during growing season	Growing season	1-2 hours	2,3,5,6
After 5+ Years of Operation (non-routine maintenance)
Activity	Frequency	Time period	Level of effort	O&M benefit^a
After long term operation of the practice, some occasional and infrequent maintenance activities might be required, such as bigger repairs, replacement of the waterproof barrier, or redesign of key elements of the practice.	As needed	As needed	Could be significant depending on the activity	1,2,3,4,5,6
^aKey to Maintenance Benefits: Proper stormwater flow and infiltration Creation and maintenance of wildlife habitat Creation and maintenance of pollinator habitat Nutrient cycling and storage Aesthetics and public enjoyment Carbon sequestration

Common problems and how to troubleshoot them for green roofs
Link to this table

Symptom	Possible causes	Solution
Standing water within the green roof for more than 72 hours	The drain pipe may be clogged with sediment or debris due to erosion or compaction	Clean the drain pipe using the access point. Address any erosion through more plantings. Limit access to the green roof to prevent compaction.
Vegetation is not able to establish	Plant selection is inappropriate for the site, they are not getting enough water or sunlight	Consult with a landscaper or horticulturist. Check that plants are suited to the local conditions. Water during the first growing season and during droughts.
Leaks inside the building	The underlying membrane may have been damaged	Identify the location and repair the damaged portion of the membrane

Maintenance Costs

Maintenance costs will vary on a number of factors, including but not limited to:

Size and design (intensive/extensive) of the green roof
Type of plantings used
Site visit frequency
Level of maintenance needed
Local weather conditions
Staffing needs (number of staff, external vs. internal staff, etc)
Travel time to site or between sites
Efficiencies of scale (single GI vs. a cluster of GI)
Equipment needed

Preventative maintenance is key to minimizing major costs associated with repairs. Green roof maintenance is crucial, especially in the first 5 years after establishment. Maintenance of the green roof for the first 5 years after installation is often included in a green roof installation contract. Maintenance costs should account for the number of hours of labor, the cost for different types of labor expertise required, and any equipment needed to successfully complete the maintenance activities.

Maintenance costs for extensive green roofs in Minnesota typically range from $0.10 to $1.00 per square foot per year after the first five years. Maintenance may be higher the first few years, while plants are being established. A study published in 2017 by ASCE shows the maintenance cost of a green roof to range from $0.0281 to $0.2821 per square foot of green roof in 2014 dollars (Clary, 2017). A 2010 report by EPA estimates maintenance costs to be between $20-40 per hour depending on the size of installation, geographic location (regional labor costs), types of plants, irrigation, and fertilizer treatments.

Useful Resources

Additional Detailed O&M Information

More detailed information regarding specific maintenance activities are provided on the page Operation and maintenance of green roofs - supplemental information. Topics discussed include

weeding,
plant replacement,
irrigation,
fertilization,
soil tests, and
photographical records.

Case Studies

Maintenance Training Documents and Videos

LiveRoof, LLC training video on maintaining a green roof.
Training and certification programs on designing, installing, and maintaining a green roof.

O&M Resource Catalog

MPCA has compiled publicly available O&M resources (Excel format) related to green infrastructure. This non-exhaustive catalog is intended as a resource to practitioners.

Example O&M plans, checklists, reports, and maintenance agreements for green roofs
Link to this table

Symptom	Possible causes
Operation & Maintenance Plan	Green Infrastructure Foundation: Living Architecture Performance Tool Example
Construction phase inspection checklist	Arlington, VA example
O&M inspection checklist	MPCA checklist MSD checklist
O&M example report	MSD example report
Maintenance Agreements	Example maintenance agreement Example maintenance agreement Example maintenance agreement

References

Arup, 2011. The Benefits and Challenges of Green Roofs on Public and Commercial Buildings. A Report to the General Services Administration.
Clary, J., Piza, H. 2017. Cost of Maintaining Green Infrastructure. American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE), Reston, VA.
Porsche, U. and M. Kohler. 2003. Life Cycle Costs of Green Roofs: A Comparison of Germany, USA, and Brazil. Presented at the World Climate and Energy Event. December 1-5, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil.

Related pages

Green Infrastructure

@@ Line 19: / Line 19: @@
 <span title="Green roofs consist of a series of layers that create an environment suitable for plant growth without damaging the underlying roof system. Green roofs create green space for public benefit, energy efficiency, and stormwater retention/ detention."> '''[https://stormwater.pca.state.mn.us/index.php?title=Green_roofs Green roofs]'''</span> are roofs that are partially or completely covered with vegetation planted in a growing <span title="Engineered media is a mixture of sand, fines (silt, clay), and organic matter utilized in stormwater practices, most frequently in bioretention practices. The media is typically designed to have a rapid infiltration rate, attenuate pollutants, and allow for plant growth."> [https://stormwater.pca.state.mn.us/index.php?title=Design_criteria_for_bioretention#Materials_specifications_-_filter_media '''medium''']</span> that is underlain by an <span title="Impermeable means not allowing something, such as water, to pass through. Some materials considered impermeable may actually allow water to pass through at very slow rates, such as 10(-8) cm/sec."> '''impermeable'''</span> barrier. This does not include roofs with vegetation that can readily be moved, such as potted vegetation. Green roofs typically consist of a series of layers (waterproof membrane, growing medium, vegetation, etc) that create an environment suitable for plant growth without damaging the underlying roof system. Green roofs create green space for public benefit, provide energy efficiency for the building, and provide stormwater retention and detention. In addition, these practices can provide <span title="Benefits derived from ecosystems and ecosystem functions. Examples of benefits include clean water, nutrient cycling, pollination, and detoxification of wastes."> '''ecosystem services'''</span> such as <span title="The movement and exchange of organic and inorganic matter back into the production of matter. Examples include the nutrient, phosphorus, and carbon cycles."> '''nutrient cycling'''</span> and storage, carbon <span title="to remove or withdraw"> '''sequestration'''</span>, reduction in <span title="an urban area having higher average temperature than its rural surroundings owing to the greater absorption, retention, and generation of heat by its buildings, pavements, and human activities."> '''heat island'''</span> effect, <span title="Adjustments in ecological, social, or economic systems in response to actual or expected climatic stimuli and their effects or impacts."> '''climate adaptation'''</span>, and habitat for bees, butterflies, and other insects and small animals that pollinate.
-Green roofs require dedicated and regular maintenance to ensure proper and long-lasting operation and ecosystem services. Estimated green roof lifespans range from 40 to 50 years, or twice as long as traditional roofs ([https://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.1062.6685&rep=rep1&type=pdf Porsche and Kohler], 2003; [https://www.gsa.gov/cdnstatic/The_Benefits_and_Challenges_of_Green_Roofs_on_Public_and_Commercial_Buildings.pdf Arup], 2011). The most frequently cited O&M concerns for green roofs include
+Green roofs require dedicated and regular maintenance to ensure proper and long-lasting operation and ecosystem services. Estimated green roof lifespans range from 40 to 50 years, or twice as long as traditional roofs ([http://www.rio12.com/rio3/proceedings/RIO3_461_U_Porsche.pdf Porsche and Kohler], 2003; [https://www.gsa.gov/cdnstatic/The_Benefits_and_Challenges_of_Green_Roofs_on_Public_and_Commercial_Buildings.pdf Arup], 2011). The most frequently cited O&M concerns for green roofs include
 *poorly drained green roofs and standing water due to poor design or drain blockage,
 *roof leaks from perforated membranes,
@@ Line 34: / Line 34: @@
 *Providing detailed specifications for the roof water-proofing membrane to prevent roof leaks.
 *If a larger green roof is intended to allow pedestrian foot traffic, designing a trail system that minimizes impact to vegetation and growing medium in order to prevent plant damage that requires maintenance/replacing, or soil compaction that could lead to flooding.
-*Providing a vegetation design plan, emphasizing <span title="A species that has been observed in the form of a naturally occurring and self-sustaining population in historical times. Non-natives do not meet this definition."> '''native species'''</span> plantings (see [https://www.pca.state.mn.us/water/plants-stormwater-design Plants for Stormwater Design] and [https://stormwater.pca.state.mn.us/index.php?title=Minnesota_plant_lists#Green_roofs this link to green roof plants]) to enhance pollinator and wildlife habitat, improve infiltration and <span title="Loss of water to the atmosphere as a result of the joint processes of evaporation and transpiration through vegetation"> '''evapotranspiration'''</span>, reduce urban <span title="an urban area having higher average temperature than its rural surroundings owing to the greater absorption, retention, and generation of heat by its buildings, pavements, and human activities."> '''heat island'''</span> effect, provide optimized <span title="The process of capturing and storing atmospheric carbon dioxide.> '''carbon sequestration'''</span>, and provide <span title="Adjustments in ecological, social, or economic systems in response to actual or expected climatic stimuli and their effects or impacts."> '''climate adaptation'''</span>. Native plantings typically require less maintenance and replacement than non-native plantings because they are adapted to the local climate.
+*Providing a vegetation design plan, emphasizing <span title="A species that has been observed in the form of a naturally occurring and self-sustaining population in historical times. Non-natives do not meet this definition."> '''native species'''</span> plantings (see [https://stormwater.pca.state.mn.us/index.php?title=Minnesota_plant_lists Plants for Stormwater Design] and [https://stormwater.pca.state.mn.us/index.php?title=Minnesota_plant_lists#Green_roofs this link to green roof plants]) to enhance pollinator and wildlife habitat, improve infiltration and <span title="Loss of water to the atmosphere as a result of the joint processes of evaporation and transpiration through vegetation"> '''evapotranspiration'''</span>, reduce urban <span title="an urban area having higher average temperature than its rural surroundings owing to the greater absorption, retention, and generation of heat by its buildings, pavements, and human activities."> '''heat island'''</span> effect, provide optimized <span title="The process of capturing and storing atmospheric carbon dioxide.> '''carbon sequestration'''</span>, and provide <span title="Adjustments in ecological, social, or economic systems in response to actual or expected climatic stimuli and their effects or impacts."> '''climate adaptation'''</span>. Native plantings typically require less maintenance and replacement than non-native plantings because they are adapted to the local climate.
 *Include site-specific plantings that take into account sun exposure, shade, interior vs exterior plantings, etc. The selection of plantings suitable to their immediate surroundings will minimize long-term care and replacement frequency.
 *Specifying the optimized soil <span title="Engineered media is a mixture of sand, fines (silt, clay), and organic matter utilized in stormwater practices, most frequently in bioretention practices. The media is typically designed to have a rapid infiltration rate, attenuate pollutants, and allow for plant growth."> [https://stormwater.pca.state.mn.us/index.php?title=Design_criteria_for_bioretention#Materials_specifications_-_filter_media '''media''']</span> composition and depth to effectively trap or sequester nutrients (phosphorus in particular), and that can also support the desired vegetation. This will also reduce maintenance in the long term.
@@ Line 127: / Line 127: @@
 ===Maintenance Training Documents and Videos===
 *[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gOcHsfay-FM LiveRoof, LLC training video] on maintaining a green roof.
-*[https://greenroofs.org/current-training Training and certification programs] on designing, installing, and maintaining a green roof.
+*[https://greenroofs.org/green-roof-professional Training and certification programs] on designing, installing, and maintaining a green roof.
-*[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YCh_xHAlZM8 Washington State Department of Ecology video] on maintaining a green roof.
 ===O&M Resource Catalog===
@@ Line 138: / Line 137: @@
 *Arup, 2011. [https://www.gsa.gov/cdnstatic/The_Benefits_and_Challenges_of_Green_Roofs_on_Public_and_Commercial_Buildings.pdf The Benefits and Challenges of Green Roofs on Public and Commercial Buildings]. A Report to the General Services Administration.
 *Clary, J., Piza, H. 2017. [https://owl.cwp.org/mdocs-posts/cost-of-maintaining-green-infrastructure/ Cost of Maintaining Green Infrastructure]. American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE), Reston, VA.
-*Porsche, U. and M. Kohler. 2003. [https://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.1062.6685&rep=rep1&type=pdf Life Cycle Costs of Green Roofs: A Comparison of Germany, USA, and Brazil]. Presented at the World Climate and Energy Event. December 1-5, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil.
+*Porsche, U. and M. Kohler. 2003. [http://www.rio12.com/rio3/proceedings/RIO3_461_U_Porsche.pdf Life Cycle Costs of Green Roofs: A Comparison of Germany, USA, and Brazil]. Presented at the World Climate and Energy Event. December 1-5, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil.
 <noinclude>
 ==Related pages==
 *[[Overview for green roofs]]
@@ Line 180: / Line 180: @@
 **[[Operation and maintenance (O&M) of permeable pavement - supplemental information]]
-[[Category:Green stormwater infrastructure operation and maintenance]]
-[[Category:Operation and maintenance]]
 [[Category:Level 3 - Best management practices/Specifications and details/Operation and maintenance]]
 </noinclude>

Difference between revisions of "Operation and maintenance (O&M) of green roofs" Operation and maintenance (O&M) of green roofs