Operation and maintenance (O&M) of swales
Revision as of 17:19, 28 January 2023 by Mtrojan (talk | contribs) (→‎Design phase O&M considerations)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)

Operation and maintenance (O&M) of swales

Image of a swale at Lino Lakes city hall

Green Infrastructure: Swales can be an important tool for retention and detention of stormwater runoff. Because they utilize vegetation, swales provide additional benefits, including cleaner air, carbon sequestration, improved biological habitat, and aesthetic value.

This page provides guidance for operation and maintenance (O&M) of swales. This includes dry swales, wet swales, bioswales, and high gradient step pools.

Supplemental information can be found on the page called Operation and maintenance of swales - supplemental information. Supplemental information includes the following.

Infiltration rate service life before clogging
Nitrogen reduction
Phosphorus reduction
Heavy metals retention
Erosion protection
Sediment monitoring, removal, and disposal
Seeding, planting, and landscaping maintenance
Snow and salt considerations
Maintenance agreements
References

Overview of typical O&M issues

A grass or dry swale is a general term for filtration or infiltration conveyance practice, but there are a wide variety of designs depending on the site requirements. The key functions of swales are to convey water with reduced peak velocities and to perform water quality treatment with filtration and infiltration. Swales have the benefit of providing ecological function in areas dominated by development and impervious surface. These practices are ideal for urban settings, which creates an opportunity for humans to impact their function through vandalism, littering, and vehicular traffic.

These practices, like other green stormwater infrastructure, require regular maintenance to ensure proper and long-lasting ecosystem and stormwater function. If properly maintained, swales can operate effectively for 20-50 years, depending on the design type. Vegetated dry swales may perform properly for up to 50 years (Malvern Borough, 2013). The most frequently cited O&M concerns for swales include the following.

Standing water in the swale after a 48 hour timeline to infiltrate runoff
Loss of volume storage due to accumulated sediment
Clogged soil media
Clogged inlet and outlet structures, or underdrains
Growth and proliferation of weeds or other non- native species that threaten the long-term effectiveness of the swale

The sections below describe best practices to prevent or minimize these common problems.

Design phase O&M considerations

Pretreatment filter strip for a bioswale.

Swales, like other infiltration practices in urban areas, may be subject to higher public visibility, greater trash loads, pedestrian traffic, vandalism, and vehicular loads. Designers should design these practices in ways that prevent or minimize O&M issues. Examples include the following.

Designing easy-access points for maintenance personnel and equipment
Limiting the contributing drainage area and sizing the practice in accordance to its contributing drainage area
Adding pretreatment and trash racks to reduce sediment and debris loads.
Providing a vegetation design plan, emphasizing the following considerations
- Utilizing native plantings that enhance pollinator and wildlife habitat, improve infiltration and erosion protection
Evapotranspiration, reduce urban heat island effect, provide optimized carbon sequestration, and provide climate adaptation. Native plantings typically require less maintenance and replacement than non-native plantings because they are adapted to the local climate (see Plants for Stormwater Design).
- Site-specific plantings that take into account sun exposure, shade, proximity to traffic corners (visibility issues), interior vs exterior plantings, salt-tolerant plants, etc. The selection of plantings suitable to their immediate surroundings will minimize long-term care and replacement frequency.
Providing educational signage for swales in residential areas to increase public awareness

Designers should consult and include any local requirements regarding green infrastructure. O&M considerations often depend on whether the practice is located on public land, private land, or in the public right of way. For example, plantings in the public right of way that conflict with any traffic safety considerations could require increased O&M, such as pruning or complete removal. Swales are particularly subject to traffic considerations and regulations, given their frequent placement in public right-of-way.

The designer should also provide a site-specific O&M plan that includes the following.

Construction inspection schedule and checklists
Post-construction routine maintenance schedule and checklists
Operating instructions for the practice (if applicable)

For more information on design criteria for dry swale (grass swales).

Construction phase O&M considerations

The modified Philip-Dunne infiltrometer, as well as other direct infiltration measurements such as double ring infiltrometers, are preferred methods for measuring infiltration rates, compared to soil borings and pits. Image: University of Minnesota, St. Anthony Falls Laboratory.

Proper construction methods and sequencing play a significant role in reducing O&M problems. Some key items during the construction phase include the following.

Before construction begins
- Install erosion control prior to excavation of swale
- Hold a pre-construction meeting to review the construction plans and the sequencing of construction
- Designate a stormwater supervisor to make sure someone is responsible for erosion and sediment control.
During construction
- Construct any pretreatment devices first to trap sediments.
- Ensure heavy equipment does not enter the footprint of the practice to avoid compaction of the growth medium
- Ensure the correct plant species are being installed by having a detailed list of species and quantities. These should be spelled out in the plan set both in the Details and Specifications and on actual drawings. A copy should be kept on one’s person at all times during construction.
- Inspect the practice during construction to ensure that the swale is built in accordance with the approved design and standards and specifications. Use a detailed inspection checklists that include sign-offs by qualified individuals at critical stages of construction, to ensure that the contractor’s interpretation of the plan is acceptable to the professional designer.
- Conduct soil infiltration tests to ensure proper soil compaction
After construction
- Verify that the swale was built in accordance with the approved design and standards and specifications
- Verify that the practice properly conveys, filters, and/or infiltrates runoff. Ensure that no standing water remains within the swale 48 hours after precipitation.
- Verify that pretreatment functions properly
- Use a detailed inspection checklists that include sign-offs by qualified individuals at the completion of construction, to ensure that the contractor’s interpretation of the plan is acceptable to the professional designer. An example construction phase inspection checklist is provided here.
- Review and discuss the plant warranty/establishment period with the plant provider to understand the conditions under which failing plants will be replaced. Divert stormwater away from BMP during establishment phase as necessary for the selected vegetation.
- Determine if stormwater should be kept offline from the practice until the seedlings are established.
- The design/construction team should provide the O&M team with the following information to be included in the O&M plan.
  - The plant warranty.
  - The as-built plans of the practice.
  - A list of conditions that might cause failure of the practice if not properly maintained.

Post-construction phase O&M

Effective short and long-term performance of grass swales requires a dedicated and routine maintenance plan with clear guidelines, expectations, and schedules. Proper maintenance will not only increase the effectiveness of the swale at treating stormwater runoff, but will create a viable green space supporting ecological function. A maintenance plan clarifying maintenance responsibilities should be required for all practices.

Some important post-construction considerations are provided below along with recommended maintenance standards.

A site-specific O&M plan should be prepared by the designer prior to completing construction of the grass swale. This plan should provide any operating procedures related to the practices. The plan should also provide clear maintenance expectations, activities, and schedules, including minimum maintenance frequencies expected. Include photos if possible. Be clear about who is responsible for the maintenance and the type of expertise that will be needed for distinct O&M activities. The O&M plan should include an anticipated budget for O&M activities. The O&M plan should also include an example O&M inspection checklist and an example maintenance report. Example O&M plans and inspection checklists are provided further down below.
A legally binding and enforceable maintenance agreement should be executed between the practice owner and the local review authority. Link here for example maintenance agreements.
Inspection and maintenance activities are distinct and can be done as separate activities or together. Inspection will typically assess the practice for any O&M issues, whereas maintenance will address the O&M issues identified by the inspection. A dedicated inspection effort on a large number of BMPs can help prioritize maintenance activities.
Maintenance activities should be careful not to cause compaction.
Ponded water that does not infiltrate within 48 hours of a storm is an indicator the swale is not functioning properly. If ponded water is observed outside of a routine O&M schedule it should be addressed immediately.
Best management practice (BMP) areas generally should not be used as dedicated snow storage areas. Snow storage within swales should be avoided when possible, such as in parking lots. Snow storage can cause compaction and increase sedimentation within the swale over time, and so snow storage on swales designed for infiltration should be specifically avoided. Link here for more information.

Overview and schedule of general maintenance activities for swales
Link to this table

First Year of Operation
Activity	Frequency	Time Period	Level of Effort	O&M Benefit¹
Check that there is no ponding	48 hours after event	All year long	1 hour	1
Inspect entire BMP after rainfall	After any event greater than 0.5”	All year long (or during area’s rain season)	2-4 hours	1
Correct earthwork if inlet scouring or unwanted flow paths develop	As needed	All year long	>4 hours	1
Spot reseed bare patches and eroding areas	As needed	First growing season	2-4 hours	3,4,5
Supplemental watering during drier periods, particularly if keeping stormwater offline until plant seedlings are established.	As needed	Dry periods	1-2 hours	3,4,5
Remove any stormwater diversion or barriers once seedlings are established.	Once	When plants are sufficiently established	1-2 hours	1,2,3,4,5
Inspect and remove invasive plants and weeds during plant community establishment	Monthly	First growing season	1-2 hours	5,6
Mowing (dry swales) side slopes and/or grass filter strip to maintain 4-12” of height	Seasonally	As needed (do not interrupt any vegetative establishment)	2-4 hours	1
After First Year of Operation
Activity	Frequency	Time Period	Level of Effort	O&M Benefit1
Check that there is no ponding	48 hours after event	All year long	1 hour	1
Inspect inlet/outlet structures for structural damage and clogging.	Annually	All year long	1-2 hours	1
Correct earthwork if inlet scouring or unwanted flow paths develop	As needed	All year long	>4 hours	1
Mowing (dry swales) side slopes and/or grass filter to maintain 4-12” of height	Seasonally	All year long	2-4 hours	1
Inspect for trash and debris	Seasonally	All year long	2-4 hours	1,5
Check for evidence of clogging in the pre-treatment device and/or in the main treatment area.	Biannually	In spring and fall	1-2 hours	1
Inspect and remove excess sediment in the pre-treatment device and/or in the main treatment area.	Annually	In spring (post- snowmelt) and fall	4 hours if removal is needed	1
Inspect plant composition and health and replace as needed (maintain >95% vegetative cover)	Biannually	In fall or spring	4 hours if plant replacement is needed	4,5
Prune and weed to maintain appearance and proper vegetative cover	As needed	Growing season	1-2 hours	4,5,6,
After 5+ Years of Operation (non-routine maintenance)
Activity	Frequency	Time Period	Level of Effort per Visit	O&M Benefit¹
After long term operation of the practice, some occasional and infrequent maintenance activities might be required, such as bigger repairs, soil regeneration, or redesign of key elements of the practice.	As needed	As needed	Could be significant depending on the activity	1,2,3,4,5,6
¹Key to Maintenance Benefits: Proper stormwater flow and infiltration Creation and maintenance of wildlife habitat Creation and maintenance of pollinator habitat Nutrient cycling and storage Aesthetics and public enjoyment Carbon sequestration

Common problems and how to troubleshoot them for swales
Link to this table

Symptom	Possible Causes	Solution
Standing water within the swale for more than 48 hours	Soil media may be clogged with accumulated sediment or the outlet structures may be clogged with trash or de	Scrape, clean or vacuum the infiltration area. A vacuum truck may be needed for sediment removal in the pretreatment area or BMP proper. All sediments may be subjected to the MPCA’s Managing Stormwater Sediment Best Management Practice Guidance. Remove any trash or debris.
Vegetation is not able to establish	Plant selection is inappropriate for the site	Consult with a landscaper or horticulturist. Check that plants are suited to the local conditions. Make sure BMP is protected from snow storage or salt application.

Maintenance costs

Maintenance costs will vary on a number of factors, including but not limited to the following.

Size of the practice and its contributing drainage area
Type of plantings used
Site visit frequency
Level of maintenance needed
Local weather conditions
Staffing needs (number of staff, external vs. internal staff, etc)
Travel time between sites
Efficiencies of scale (single GI vs. a cluster of GI)
Equipment needed

Maintenance costs will vary depending on the size of the practice, its contributing drainage area, type of plantings, and whether it is part of a larger green infrastructure effort. Preventative maintenance is key to minimizing major costs associated with repairs. A general rule of thumb to estimate annual maintenance costs is 5%-7% of the installation costs for swales (CWP, 2017). In 2014 dollars, the annual cost of maintenance is approximately $0.06-$0.12 per square foot of practice, which adjusts to $0.07-$0.14 in 2021 dollars, as estimated in the National Stormwater Calculator (Clary, 2017). Maintenance may be higher the first few years, while plants are being established.

Maintenance costs should account for the number of hours of labor, the cost for different types of labor expertise required, and any equipment needed to successfully complete the maintenance activities.

Useful resources

Additional detailed O&M information

More detailed information regarding specific maintenance activities are provided here. Topics discussed include

sustainable service life for infiltration and bioretention BMPs;
erosion protection and sediment monitoring, removal, and disposal;
seeding, planting, and landscaping maintenance;
snow and salt considerations;
maintenance agreements; and
aditional References.

Case studies

Grass Swales: Gauging Their Ability to Remove Pollutants From Highway Stormwater Runoff - Wisconsin DOT, 2007.

Maintenance training documents and videos

Training and certification programs on designing, installing, and maintaining stormwater BMPs.

Example O&M plans, checklists, reports, and maintenance agreements for swales
Link to this table

Document	Link
Operation & Maintenance Plan
Construction phase inspection checklist	Dry Swale - construction inspection checklist Wet Swale - construction inspection checklist
O&M inspection checklist	Dry Swale - operation and maintenance checklist Wet Swale - operation and maintenance checklist
O&M example report
Maintenance Agreements	Example Maintenance Agreement 1 Example Maintenance Agreement 2 Example Maintenance Agreement 3

References

Malvern Borough. 2013. Vegetated Swales.
Clary, J., Piza, H. 2017. Cost of Maintaining Green Infrastructure. American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE), Reston, VA.

Related pages

Green Infrastructure

Operation and maintenance (O&M) of swales Revision as of 17:19, 28 January 2023 by Mtrojan (talk | contribs) (→‎Design phase O&M considerations)(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff) Operation and maintenance (O&M) of swales

Contents